Medical Students' Training For a Final Examination in Surgery - The Technion Experience


Journal article


N. Rosenberg, R. Nave, Zeev Gazit Ma, S. Reis, M. Soudry, A. Sternberg
2007

Semantic Scholar
Cite

Cite

APA   Click to copy
Rosenberg, N., Nave, R., Ma, Z. G., Reis, S., Soudry, M., & Sternberg, A. (2007). Medical Students' Training For a Final Examination in Surgery - The Technion Experience.


Chicago/Turabian   Click to copy
Rosenberg, N., R. Nave, Zeev Gazit Ma, S. Reis, M. Soudry, and A. Sternberg. “Medical Students' Training For a Final Examination in Surgery - The Technion Experience” (2007).


MLA   Click to copy
Rosenberg, N., et al. Medical Students' Training For a Final Examination in Surgery - The Technion Experience. 2007.


BibTeX   Click to copy

@article{n2007a,
  title = {Medical Students' Training For a Final Examination in Surgery - The Technion Experience},
  year = {2007},
  author = {Rosenberg, N. and Nave, R. and Ma, Zeev Gazit and Reis, S. and Soudry, M. and Sternberg, A.}
}

Abstract

There is a controversy on the best educational method for improving medical graduates' achievements in final examinations. We hypothesize that final "tuning" of knowledge by a mock examination is effective for success in the final examination. In the years 2003-2005, graduates of the Faculty of Medicine in Technion, Israel Institute of Tech- nology were exposed to mock examinations in general surgery and surgical sub-specialties. The 2004 and 2005 examinations were validated. The standardized (according to the annual national average) scores were compared for graduates in 2003-2005 and 2002. There was no significant change in the results among Technion graduates for the year 2003 na - tional examination compared to the year 2002, but in 2004 and 2005 the Technion graduates sig- nificantly improved their standardized scores compared to the 2002 graduates (p=0.01, p<0.001 respectively). There was no additional educational intervention in the curriculum for the years 2003-2005 in comparison to the 2002 class. Therefore we suggest that a validated mock exami- nation, designed according to the final examination format combined with a debriefing session, improves the medical graduate's achievements in the final certification examination. According to the Israeli Higher Education author- ity the requirements for the MD certification of medical school graduates include a successful pass of a national examination in general surgery and the surgical subspe- cialties at the minimal score of 60%. The performance in this examination should reflect the level of knowledge of the graduates in different aspects of surgery at a level sufficient for their future general practice, providing that the test is validated at the reliability level of at least 0.8 (Novik MR and Lewis C 1967, Cronbach LJ 1951). In the Ruth & Bruce Rappaport Faculty of Medicine, Technion- Israel Institute of Technology, the students are instructed in general surgery and the surgical subspecialties during focused clerkships of 7 weeks during the fifth year of their studies. An additional 15 weeks are dedicated to the sur- gical sub-specialties' clerkships during the sixth year of studies. There are nine general surgery, four orthopaedics, three intensive care, four urologic, two plastic surgery and two vascular surgery wards that are affiliated with the faculty of medicine and involved in clinical teaching of the students. Although the surgical teaching curriculum is uniform for all the teaching wards, some deviations in in- struction and emphasis on the important subjects can oc- cur according to the personal preferences of the lecturers and tutors. Therefore, a final controlled "tuning" of the provided knowledge might be important in order to reach a desired uniform level of knowledge that is essential for the students' success in the final examination. Because